« Rock and Awe: Countdown to Guitarmageddon | Main | The 'Hood » super mc plus t900

December 21, 2006

Stupid Ideas

Since some people don't appreciate Adam's linkblog as much as I do, I am going to rehash one of his entries from earlier this week. super mc plus t900

The story is that David Sklansky, an author and poker player, has issued a challenge to the nation's Christians:


We will both take the math SAT or GRE (aptidude test). Your choice. We will both have only half the normally allotted time to lessen the chances of a perfect score. Lower score pays higher score $50,000.super mc plus t900

To qualify you must take a reputable polygraph that proclaims you are truthful when you state that:

  1. You are at least 95% sure that Jesus Christ came back from the dead.

  2. You are at least 95% sure that adults who die with the specific belief that Jesus probably wasn't ressurected will not go to heaven.
super mc plus t900

Mr. Sklansky goes on to state that he is attempting to prove that in order to be a Christian you have to be stupid. super mc plus t900

Of course, this itself is a pretty stupid idea. Jeopardy champion and devoted Mormon Ken Jennings has already volunteered to take his fifty grand. Few people in the world believe stupider shit than Mormons, but they don't have to be stupid -- or, more specifically, bad at math -- to do so.super mc plus t900

Posted by todd at December 21, 2006 8:55 PMsuper mc plus t900

Comments

It's because of morons like this that atheists get a bad rap.super mc plus t900

I recently remarked to a friend in passing that I am an atheist. A long while later, this conversation occurred:super mc plus t900

Me: Yea, I don't have big plans for Christmas.
Her: Well, of course not.
Me: Huh?
Her: You're an atheist.super mc plus t900

The thing is, I normally do celebrate Christmas (and I do call it Christmas). It's just that my folks are in China for the holidays so I have no family here to celebrate it with.super mc plus t900

This is why I sometimes tell people that I'm agnostic even though it's not the truth. Say "atheist" and you'll need to spend the next half hour explaining that you don't actually stab babies and shit on the homeless.super mc plus t900

I guess this comment is actually more related to your post about Dawkins but oh well.super mc plus t900

Posted by: Bo at December 21, 2006 10:15 PMsuper mc plus t900

Wait, you don't stab babies? Dude, we're going to have to take back your membership card.super mc plus t900

Posted by: todd. at December 21, 2006 10:28 PMsuper mc plus t900

I just noticed that Sean Carroll at Cosmic Variance covered this as well.super mc plus t900

Posted by: todd. at December 22, 2006 6:19 AMsuper mc plus t900

I may have less of a tendency to identify with groups than most, but I don't think of Sklansky as reflecting poorly on atheists by being an asshole -- rather, he's just an asshole. In this case, he happens to be an asshole about atheism. In fact, I'd go further and say that the urge to caricature believers as dumb rubes isn't unique to atheists, but is simple a specific form of the general human tendency to be assholes to each other.super mc plus t900

Posted by: Adam at December 24, 2006 2:22 PMsuper mc plus t900

Also, I should point out that Sklansky is not just a poker player and author, but one of the most prominent and well-respected poker theorists. Just to point out that, just as people who are stupid (from an atheist perspective) about faith need not also be stupid about numbers, Sklansky's genius with numbers doesn't prevent him from being stupid about people.super mc plus t900

Posted by: Adam at December 24, 2006 2:24 PMsuper mc plus t900

I linked to the same article. However, he doesn't appear to have a lot more wins than you'd expect from a decent player who's been persistent for a long time, and all of his books are published by a house he owns, so I wasn't sure how much stock to put into that claim. If you've heard independent verification, that's interesting news.super mc plus t900

Posted by: todd. at December 24, 2006 6:23 PMsuper mc plus t900

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)super mc plus t900 (If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?
super mc plus t900


super mc plus t900